Beauty, Buying Guides

The Best Organic Eyeliners that are Cruelty Free, Vegan and Care About the World!

These days, most brands are cruelty free and have some consciousness of being environmentally friendly.

We are obsessed with eyeliner here, having already reviewed the best Japanese eyeliners, the best Korean eyeliners and the best eyeliners for tightlining. Now we have rounded up our top 10 favorites of the best Organic and Natural Eyeliners on the market.

HOW TO CHOOSE THE BEST ORGANIC EYELINER

Organic Rating

  • Some brands have organic pencils, natural, or certified organic pencils. We fill you in.

Where is it Made

  • We let you know where each organic eyeliner is made. Is it made in the USA or China?

Type

  • Is it a pencil or liquid eyeliner? We found out for you.

# of Colors

  • We fill you on on how many colors the pencil is available in

THE BEST ORGANIC EYELINER

Organic Eyeliner

Name

Organic Rating

Where it's made

Type

#of colors

best-travel-daypack-hikpro

Inika

Certified Organic

Sydney

Pencil

6

best-korean-bb-cream-missha-m

Jane Iredale

Organic

N/A

Pencil

7

Ecco Bella

Natural

Mexico

Pencil

5

Zuzu Luxe

Natural

USA

Liquid

8

Mineral Fusion

Natural

N/A

Pencil

5

best-travel-daypack-free-knight

Au Naturale

Natural

USA

Pencil

5

best-travel-daypack-roveasy-small-daypack

Avril

Certified Organic

Pencil

France

6

Jes Organics

Natural

Pencil

USA

5

INIKA Organic Eyeliner

Certified Organic

Pencil

Sydney

6 color choices

Inika's Organic eyeliners are certified organic and they are definitely our number one pick because their eyeliner is award winning. Organic eyeliners tend to be less smooth than non-organic eyeliners but Inika's eyeliners are super creamy and glide onto the skin.

Only natural minerals and plant ingredients were used to formulate these eyeliners. The Inika eyeliners are available in 6 different colors and they were great for sensitive eyes. We love that it comes with a built-in sharpener, which is always a major bonus.

This eyeliner offers great flexibility as the built-in sharpener allows you to draw a more smudged line or a super sharp line, whatever you prefer! Cruelty-free and vegan , this is definitely our #1 pick for the best organic eyeliner.



Jane Iredale Eye Pencil

best-travel-daypack-hikpro

Organic

Pencil

N/A

7 color choices

Jane Iredale's pencils contain Vitamin E, Shea Butter, Jojoba Oil and Macadamia Seed Oil to treat your skin. It is a mineral based pencil which is gentle on your skin. It is long lasting and it doesn't smudge and its easy to remove at the end of the day. 

One thing is that you do need to use Jane Iredale's sharpeners with their pencils, which you have to buy separately. Other sharpeners tend to break the wood of the pencil and damage the product. These eyeliners are available in seven colors: basic black, basic brown, black and brown, black and gray, midnight blue, taupe, and white.

We love that you can get a nice defined line with these eyeliner pencils. The caps are sturdy and stay in place so you don't have to worry about the pencil marking up the inside of your purse. This is a great pick for a solid, natural liner!

100% - Creamy Liner

best-travel-daypack-roveasy-small-daypack

Organic

Pencil

USA

4 color choices

​Next up we have 100 Percent Pure's creamy long lasting, organic liner which is made in the USA in Silicon Valley. This pencil is completely free of toxins and formulated with the most high quality of ingredients. 

These eyeliners are super creamy and glide on smoothly but if you have oily lids you will probably need to reapply throughout the day. ​They are available in four different colors: blackest black, dark cacao, gleaming pewter and royal.

Avril - Eyeliner Pencil

Best Korean Lip Patch - Etude House Cherry Lip Mask

Certified Organic

Pencil

France

6 color choices

​Avril's eyeliner is Ecocert Certified Organic. This is important to note because its not incredibly common. Many of the organic eyeliners on this list are not certified organic. Avril's eyeliner is extremely affordable and features organic beeswax and shea butter to treat the eyes.

This eyeliner is long lasting and doesn't tug at the eyes.​ Avril's products are subjected to strict quality control standards and the products are produced in France. If you are searching for an organic certified eyeliner at a bargain price, this pencil is it!

Ecco Bella - Eyeliner Pencil

best-travel-daypack-free-knight

Natural

Pencil

Mexico

5 color choices

Ecco Bella's Natural Eyeliner is made from vegetable waxes and it is preservative free and gluten Free. Since there are no toxins or chemicals present in it's formula, its a perfect fit for sensitive eyes. We love that the eyeliner glides on easily.

Using palm and palm kernel glycerides the eyeliner applies easily without tugging or pulling at the delicate skin around your eyes. Ecco Bella believes so much in its products that they all come with a 100% satisfaction guarantee.

This eyeliner is available in five colors and it doesn't smudge. The brand Ecco Bella is on a mission to create a non-toxic world and their products are developed via a combination of dermatology, nutrition and alternative medicine.

Zuzu Luxe - Liquid Eyeliner

best-travel-daypack-venture-pal-daypack

Natural

Liquid

USA

8 color choices

Next up we have Zuzu Luze's Organic Liquid Eyeliner. Liquid eyeliners are definitely more rare in the world of organic cosmetics. This formula is 100% Vegan Certified and Gluten Free. It also contains plant waxes and vitamins to leave your lashes conditioned and healthy.

This liquid eyeliner is also water resistant and has a matte finish. It comes with a nice firm and flexible brush and the eyeliner is easy to apply.  We also appreciate that Zuzu Luxe is super transparent and has all its ingredients for the eyeliner posted.

Whats also great is that the eyeliner is super pigmented​. We love that it is very reasonably priced also. If you are sensitive to commercial makeup, this is a great pick!

Mineral Fusion - Eye Pencil

best-travel-daypack-bago-lightweight-daypack

Natural

Pencil

N/A

5 color choices

Mineral Fusion's eye pencils are super velvety and mineral-rich. Their product is gluten free, 100% vegan, cruelty free, paraben free, artificial color free, fragrance free, talc free, hypo-allergenic  and phthalate free. meadowfoam, vitamin E, and chamomile are added to treat your skin.

It washes off easily but you may need to reapply throughout the day. The Mineral Fusion pencils apply smoothly without tugging the skin. It works best under your eyes and you may have to go over it more than one time but the color is nice and rich.

These pencils are available in five colors: coal, azure, rough, touch and organic. Some of the names aren't a great indication of the color so just click on the link to check them out for yourself! This is a solid pick for an organic eyeliner to add to your collection.

Au Naturale - Organic Eye Liner Pencil

best-travel-daypack-wasing-50l-daypack

Natural

Pencil

USA

5 color choices

We give bonus points to Au Naturale's eyeliners because they are made right here in the US of A in Green Bay, Washington. The eyeliner will arrive safety sealed and you can use any eyeliner sharpener with this pencil.

It stays on pretty well but you may need to reapply throughout the day. This pencil is non irritating but another issue is that you will need to resharpen it quite a bit more often than other eyeliners. These eyeliners are paraben-free, fragrance-free, gluten-free, bismuth oxychloride-free, non-nano, carmine-free, vegan, and cruelty-free.

Au Naturale eyeliners are available in 5 colors: amethyst, coco, night, deep sea, meadow, and mint. Just click on the link below to see great photos of the color options. If you want to support a great product which is ethically produced in every way and based in the United States, you have to go with Au Naturale's eyeliners!

Jillian Dempsey - Natural Khôl Eyeliner

best-travel-daypack-roveasy-small-daypack

Natural

Pencil

Czech Republic

2 color choices

Jillian Dempsey's Natural Khôl Eyeliner is a premium eyeliner with a built in smudger to give you that perfect smoky eye look. It is formulated with organic shea butter,  marula oil and organic jojoba oil to treat your skin.

Jillian Dempsey is a celebrity makeup artist and she knows her products! This liner is long lasting but it is not as creamy as some of the eyeliners on this list. It doesn't smudge and its great for sensitive eyes!

Jes Organics - Eyeliner Pencil

Best Korean Lip Patch - Etude House Cherry Lip Mask

Natural

Pencil

USA

5 color choices

Last up we have Jes Organic's eyeliner. It's completely natural and the ingredients are Castor Oil, Jojoba Oil, Candelilla Wax, Beeswax, Mica, Iron Oxides. The brand explained to me that the eyeliner was all natural but not promoted as "organic" which is super confusing since the brand has "organic" in it's name.

Jes Organics is a Christian based company based in the United States. Their products are made with the highest of quality, organic ingredients and everything is cruelty free. 


NylonPink.tv is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com. CERTAIN CONTENT THAT APPEARS ON THIS SITE COMES FROM AMAZON SERVICES LLC. THIS CONTENT IS PROVIDED 'AS IS' AND IS SUBJECT TO CHANGE OR REMOVAL AT ANY TIME. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on Amazon.com at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product. All prices on this site may change and those considered valid are displayed on Amazon.com

Write a comment

CommentLuv badge